Rank lists and cheatsheets can be deceiving when they're presented without commentary. Our rankings have been vastly improved by adding staffer comments, but it can be hard to see the all-important context in the consensus rankings and sheets. It's critical to know where a significant drop-off in fantasy value occurs. A simple rank list can't tell you if the DL4 is closer in value to the DL10 than the DL3. A cheatsheet can't tell you if the ranker feels the LB10 is a boom-bust play with LB2 upside and LB40 downside while the LB11 has a much narrower range of expectation.
That's where tiers are helpful.
Using tiers allows you to lump and split players in context. Using tiers can help keep you on the right side of draft runs. Seeing that you have five linebackers of equal value left on your board might prompt you to take a player at another position. Noting that there's only one wide receiver left before a major drop in value will show you when you must draft a position sooner than expected. A tiered draft board keeps you from making panicked decisions while on the clock.
HOW TO USE THE TIERS
Note 1: These tiers are based on 2015 expectation in a balanced IDP scoring system. I stopped producing dynasty rankings years ago when it became clear I weighted the current season significantly more than future seasons. In deeper dynasty leagues, I'll save a roster slot for a strong developmental prospect but otherwise still use these tiers as my primary roster philosophy. A separate dynasty stash tier is included at the end of each positional article.
Note 2: I'm basing positional classifications on the MFL database (which syncs to the Rotoworld depth charts). Early in the offseason, I'll deviate from the Rotoworld depth chart when I'm reasonably certain a positional change is coming that Rotoworld will reflect later in the offseason.
Note 3: I'll add a ^^^ for those players making a move up in my tiers and vvv for those players who have dropped since the previous tier release. For reference, you'll be able to see the earlier versions of these tier articles within the IDP article list, but the trend column should help you see where player movement is happening within the tiers at a quick glance. I'll also be including an ADP column after training camp begins. The ADP number will be an average of our FBG rankings, the FantasyPros Consensus Rankings, and ADP data from drafts at MFL.
Finally, the date on this article represents the last time the tiers were updated. Each update will be published as a stand-alone article. Make sure you are viewing the most recent tier article by checking the complete IDP article list here.
That's a long, but necessary, introduction to the important stuff. Thanks for bearing with me.
Ten years ago, the defensive back position used to be one of my favorite areas to rank. Offenses were straightforward, base defenses were stable and teams rarely platooned players. If you had a working knowledge of the coverages a team preferred to run and the skill sets of the secondary, you could make smart, consistent bets on which players were likely to see the most statistical opportunity.
Unfortunately, the league isn't simple anymore.
According to ProFootballFocus data, an average of 70 safeties and 83 cornerbacks have played at least 500 snaps over the past three seasons. The trend toward heavy subpackage use isn't new information and shouldn't be surprising to any fan of defensive football, but it's still striking to see 153 defensive backs per season averaging 30 snaps per game.
The defensive line and linebacker groups have significantly fewer players reach that plateau, with around 100 players each.
Not all of those snaps are created equally. Game situation, down and distance, personnel and surrounding cast have much more to do with the fantasy upside of any given snap than ever before. Free safeties moving to the slot, strong safeties moving to linebacker and non-starters moving into a key tackling role on subpackage downs are becoming more and more common. It's become very difficult to project yearly and weekly tackle numbers for defensive backs.
And that's changed my roster philosophy for defensive backs over the past 3-5 seasons. I now believe that there are two main tiers for DB-inclusive leagues. The first tier includes the players I believe have Elite DB1 potential -- 80+ solo tackles or 60+ solos with elite peripheral coverage stat (FF/INT/PD) upside. The second tier includes everyone else.
It's also important to have a short memory. If an "Elite DB" isn't performing as such, move on. It's okay for your defensive back roster spots to remain fluid all season long.
I'll still be lumping and splitting players into tiers in this feature. But realize that every single defensive back that could see 40 or more snaps in a given week belongs somewhere in the matchup cloud. You're probably thinking, "Come on, Bramel. That's almost 200 players." Yup. Get used to it. Nickel and dime corners and hybrid nickel safeties may hold just as much fantasy value as a starting cornerback or safety.
Scouting IDPs is as much about scouting opportunity as talent. The paradigm has changed. We've adapted to front seven rotations and nickel linebacker specialists in recent seasons. It's time to do the same with the defensive backs.
HIGH FLOOR ELITE SAFETIES | DB1
Unexpectedly elite fantasy options present themselves in the early weeks every year. If you're aggressive on the waiver wire in the first month, you can often stumble onto a player you planned to stream who becomes too valuable to dump back on the free agent list. Still, if these elite options remain available after the best offensive depth and highest DE/LB upside is gone, snap them up. They are the best combination of upside and floor on the board this season.
|Morgan Burnett||<>||DB2||Aligns in box more frequently than Clinton-Dix; unknowns persist at ILB|
|Reshad Jones||<>||DB3||Averaging 83 solos per 16 games over past three seasons; capable in coverage|
|Eric Weddle||<>||DB4||All-around stud w/ questionable ILBs; unhappiness w/ contract will pay dividends|
|T.J. McDonald||<>||DB6||Was Fisher’s in-the-box safety last year and should be again|
|Harrison Smith||<>||DB1||May not have 100 solo upside but has 70 solo floor & strong coverage profile|
HIGH VARIANCE SAFETIES | WEEKLY DB1 UPSIDE
Target these players late in your draft if you miss out on the elite options. There will be more DB3- weeks from this group than the one above, but the majority of this group will be solid every week fantasy starters.
|Barry Church||<>||DB8||Steady production but possible increase in variance w/ return of Sean Lee|
|Johnathan Cyprien||<>||DB5||Should be recovered from hand injury for W1|
|Antoine Bethea||<>||DB9||Steady vet who should benefit from increased opportunity and questions at ILB|
|Tyrann Mathieu||<>||DB16||Will be back playing full time but stronger competition for tackles than 2013|
|Kenny Vaccaro||<>||DB23||Huge disappointment poss injury related; PFF recorded 19!! missed tackles|
|Ha Ha Clinton-Dix||<>||DB10||Able to put up 63 solo last year; coverage stats should improve|
|Landon Collins||<>||DB7||Should see lots of time in the box behind average linebacker group|
|Michael Griffin||<>||DB15||Loads of opportunity again this year; solid ball skills will help|
|Charles Woodson||<>||DB18||Do not expect 80 solos again; careful not to overdraft|
|Earl Thomas||<>||DB14||Two seasons with ~70 solos now; coverage value gives him elite weekly upside|
|Calvin Pryor||<>||DB33||Will be used to strengths around the box this year|
|Antrel Rolle||<>||DB12||May not see slot snaps to push him into elite tier but still very good|
|Rashad Johnson||<>||DB20||Looks likely to remain base strong safety over Bucannon for now|
|Da’Norris Searcy||<>||DB17||Productive when plays; should get every-down chance in TEN|
|Kam Chancellor||<>||DB13||My favorite NFL safety but opportunity and home stat crew kill his floor|
|Ron Parker||<>||DB48||Strong 2014 and listed as starting SS on first KC depth chart|
|Deone Bucannon||<>||DB25||59 solos in 700 snaps last year; vaults up list if wins every-down job|
BEST EARLY SEASON STREAMING SAFETIES | WEEKLY DB2 UPSIDE
Target these players in deeper leagues as early season DB3 lineup options. Do not hesitate to stream any of these players on and off your roster unless you can identify a clear cause (talent, opportunity, scheme) for a strong early season performance.
|Mike Adams||<>||DB31||ILBs not as rangy as you think; coverage upside in passing shootouts|
|Robert Blanton||<>||DB38||Steady last year but competition for tackles steep|
|James Ihedigbo||<>||DB21||Quietly strong run defender last year w/ big play upside|
|Donte Whitner||<>||DB22||Floor decent due to assist heavy stat crew but nothing special|
|Malcolm Jenkins||<>||DB34||Inconsistent and now stuck behind two elite rangy ILBs|
|Duke Ihenacho||<>||Still ahead of Jeron Johnson in early camp work; durability issues|
|Devin McCourty||<>||DB57||Hard to project behind stud front seven but coverage upside remains|
|Bradley McDougald||<>||DB39||Lovie Smith favorite who isn't being seriously challenged by Swearinger in camp|
|T.J. Ward||<>||DB27||Has yet to blossom into consistent tackler in DEN despite favorable role|
|Jairus Byrd||<>||DB35||Returning from injury but should have weekly upside v good matchups|
|Rahim Moore||<>||Will have more coverage than run responsibility but HOU ILB are ugly|
|Dashon Goldson||<>||DB54||Veteran could end up most productive DB in WAS|
|Aaron Williams||<>||DB49||Has big play value but questionable tackle upside|
|Shamarko Thomas||<>||DB47||Inexperienced but opportunity in the box gets him listed|
|Will Hill||<>||DB64||Favorable stat crew; no rotation with Elam done for season|
I'm still watching these players and situations closely. I really like the Washington and Houston safety opportunity. Tyvon Branch, Eric Berry, Mark Barron, and D.J. Swearinger Sr remain listed, though none look likely to be more than streaming options early.
|Tyvon Branch||<>||DB19||Currently running behind Parker and Abdullah|
|Eric Berry||<>||DB26||Working back into contact and football shape; wouldn\'t bet on more than rotation|
|Mark Barron||<>||DB72||Filled subpackage role for STL well but not in line for full time duty|
|D.J. Swearinger Sr||<>||DB59||Claimed by TB ahead of more fantasy-friendly teams but Bucs like McDougald|
|Eddie Pleasant||<>||Competing with Andre Hal; winner will have streaming value|
Recommended for deeper dynasty rosters only, this group isn't likely to impact your 2015 fantasy roster without an injury or unexpected depth chart surprise.
|Clayton Geathers||<>||DB75||Continues to generate buzz; already working in various subpackages|
|Adrian Amos||^^^||Now rotating with first team; upside limited even if he wins job|
|Ibraheim Campbell||<>||May supplant Whitner sooner than later; could be hybrid nickel LB option|
|Jaquiski Tartt||<>||Size and speed to be Chancellor clone but will need extensive seasoning|
|Shawn Williams / Derron Smith||<>||Neither has made much progress in competition with Nelson/Iloka|
|James Sample||<>||Broken arm in OTAs may have cost him starting job this season|
|Cedric Thompson||<>||Time may come sooner with Louis Delmas ACL injury|
Historically, you could do well at cornerback by grabbing the most physical players or trolling for Tampa-2 starters. That's not the case any longer.
What I tend to favor now is:
- A physical corner who will shed blocks and defend the run.
- A confident corner with good ball skills.
- A versatile corner who plays outside, then slides into the slot in subpackages.
- A decent corner playing opposite a stud cover corner.
- A corner who plays more zone coverage than man coverage.
- A corner for a team likely to see above-average passing attempts.
- A corner playing for a team likely to see high tackle opportunity with weak front seven tacklers.
The more criteria a player fits, the more attractive they are to me. But it's not always predictive. There will be players who finish in the top five who do not fit the criteria well. Minimal investment, a short memory, trend analysis and some film study will help you navigate the week-to-week variance here.
This season, I see two elite talents and a long list of solid streamable options.
CORNERBACKS W/ EVERY WEEK DB1 VALUE
I love Prince Amukamara but he needs to get over another soft tissue strain and start practicing before I'll draft him in this range right now. I think McCourty will still hold value this season, but he's not too far ahead of the players listed in the streaming tier.
|Prince Amukamara||<>||DB24||Over past two seasons projects to 75 solos/16 games; elite two way CB|
|Jason McCourty||<>||DB11||Model of consistency at inconsistent position|
ROSTERABLE CORNERBACKS W/ PROJECTABLE FLOOR
There's no reason not to take shots at upside early in the season, even in leagues where you are required to start two cornerbacks. Every owner is dealing with variance at this position. I'll routinely swing and swing again at talent and opportunity in players like Fuller, Hayward and Verrett. The key is to move quickly in and out of your shares. If they start slow, don't hesitate to move on. Should they later show signs of life, move immediately to re-roster and don't wait for them to establish a trend before adding them again.
|Chris Harris Jr||<>||DB76||No longer underrated and should still see lots of slot snaps|
|Casey Hayward||<>||DB66||Now full time and could be elite fantasy option immediately|
|Kyle Fuller||<>||DB29||Doesn’t get Tampa-2 bump anymore but will be consistent all-around threat|
|Cary Williams||<>||DB101||Move to Seattle will only help and good tackling mentality should fit in|
|Joe Haden||<>||DB28||Teams don’t shy away from him as much as you’d think|
|Jason Verrett||<>||DB77||Rookie year derailed by shoulder surgery; excellent skill set opposite Flowers|
|Buster Skrine||<>||Still projects to slot with NYJ and has quietly been Richard Marshall 2.0|
|Charles Tillman||<>||DB40||Looks likely to start but new scheme and surrounding cast may limit him|
|William Gay||<>||DB108||High floor option who won’t kill you in any week|
|Alterraun Verner||<>||DB36||Still valuable outside the high volume TEN defense|
|Byron Maxwell||<>||DB84||Can handle CB1 duties in PHI and volume is attractive|
|Bradley Roby||<>||DB51||Broncos list him at CB on their depth chart; likely to play slot|
|Xavier Rhodes||<>||DB105||Like his fantasy profile but this is more projection than reality for now|
|Desmond Trufant||<>||DB52||Safe high floor option but tackle upside limited|
|Johnathan Joseph||<>||DB41||70 solos last season likely an anomaly but useful streaming option|
|Ronald Darby||<>||Getting look opposite Gilmore w/ McKelvin\'s ankle setback|
|Jerraud Powers||<>||DB90||Worth a look opposite Peterson at home v solid WR|
|Orlando Scandrick||<>||DB104||Not much upside here but worth keeping on your streaming shortlist|
This is a really strong group of rookie corners. All of these players will get an extended look in their first two seasons and many have a primo rookie corner profile.
|Aaron Colvin||<>||Already threatening to start after recovering from ACL tear last spring|
|Eric Rowe||<>||DB112||Should eventually be a stud w/ all-around game|
|Damarious Randall||<>||Surprised GB planning to use him at CB but gives him big upside|
|Kevin Johnson||<>||Good profile especially if he starts opposite Joseph next year|
|Jalen Collins||<>||Scouting report is strong and opportunity could come soon|
|Marcus Peters||<>||May be best pure corner in class but fantasy profile questionable|
|Senquez Golson||<>||Opportunity in PIT will come quickly|
|Trae Waynes||<>||DB73||Good prospect without strong fantasy profile|
|D’Joun Smith||<>||May be some time before he can fulfill fantasy promise|
Follow and ask questions on Twitter @JeneBramel. Reading the Defense will be a regular feature this offseason with free agent commentary, draft prospect previews, tier discussion, links to our offseason IDP roundtable podcasts and much more. Subscribe to The Audible on iTunes or download our IDP podcast here.