This year's series of "By Committee" articles sparked a few great questions from the readers, and that led to a recent article where I discussed using a few different approaches (such as Ben Roethlisberger only at home plus another quarterback). At the end of the article, a table was presented to show several options at quarterback for committee pairs that involved quarterbacks that were higher than the cutoff line that I had drawn (QB13+ on the ADP list). The readers asked why the line was drawn at QB12, and I felt that it was a good question and a different answer (and article) was needed. Further investigation of this seemlingly arbitrary line led me to ask the question for wide receiver - should the line be drawn higher, and could better pairs result?
So with this in mind, I revisited the arguments I made about the committee approach, and then I explored raising the line (and the bar) for better pairs. Below are the results, which I hope help you on your fantasy draft day:
ELIGIBLE RECEIVERS
I mentioned this the first time - defenses and quarterbacks are relatively easy to "committee" together. There's usually only one QB and certainly only one team defense per NFL club, so the approach is pretty simple as far as picking out which players / teams to try and pair up. When it comes to wide receivers, the line is not quite so easy to draw, but I needed some basis to pick which players it made sense to try and combine for a decent committee. This time I decided that I would use the following criteria to decide which players to start with for evaluating:
CRITERIA #1 - WR11 AND BEYOND
This seems pretty simple. If we want to have a duo that puts up elite numbers, that means we want WR10 or better production - else we would just draft a Top 10 option and forget the whole idea. So here is the list of players with which I started, based on their Average Draft Position (ADP):
ADP | Player | ADP | Player |
WR11 | Demaryius Thomas | WR23 | Golden Tate |
WR12 | DeAndre Hopkins | WR24 | Sammy Watkins |
WR13 | Brandin Cooks | WR25 | Jarvis Landry |
WR14 | Doug Baldwin | WR26 | Davante Adams |
WR15 | Tyreek Hill | WR27 | Kelvin Benjamin |
WR16 | Alshon Jeffery | WR28 | Brandon Marshall |
WR17 | Allen Robinson | WR29 | Stefon Diggs |
WR18 | Michael Crabtree | WR30 | Tyrell Williams |
WR19 | Keenan Allen | WR31 | DeSean Jackson |
WR20 | Martavis Bryant | WR32 | DeVante Parker |
WR21 | Emmanuel Sanders | WR33 | Terrelle Pryor |
WR22 | Larry Fitzgerald |
Table 1: Wide Receivers WR11-30+ Based on ADP
Now we have 23 guys to pair up and see how they do. That makes 253 potential committees, so there had better be a decent one (or several, we hope) out of all of those couplets. Now, before I go over the method of how to pair them up and the results, we need one more rule:
CRITERIA #2 - NO MORE THAN ONE WR FROM ROUND 7 AND ONE FROM ROUND 8
Rather than keep Criteria #2 from the original article, I am allowing for more flexibility in your draft. Let us let the results speak for themselves and then decide which pairs are the correct ones to select as the draft progresses.
So what do we do now to figure out some WR pairs?
CRITERIA #3 - USE FOOTBALLGUYS' WR STRENGTH OF SCHEDULE
This sounds pretty simple, doesn't it? Just take the WR Strength of Schedule to figure out when certain players are more likely to score well. What I did is similar to what the Projections Dominator and Draft Dominator do for you - take the projected fantasy points and slice them up over 17 weeks based on the strength of schedule. I call this result the "distributed fantasy points" for each receiver.
After I had all 23 wide receivers with distributed fantasy points on a weekly basis, I just compared all of the possible WR pairs to find the best duos for WR3BC. So here we are - time for some results:
Rank | Wide Receiver 1 | Wide Receiver 2 | Value |
1 | Demaryius Thomas | Brandin Cooks | 180.09 |
2 | Brandin Cooks | Doug Baldwin | 178.2 |
3 | DeAndre Hopkins | Brandin Cooks | 177.04 |
4 | Demaryius Thomas | Doug Baldwin | 176.03 |
5 | DeAndre Hopkins | Tyreek Hill | 174.95 |
6 | Demaryius Thomas | DeAndre Hopkins | 174.29 |
7 | Demaryius Thomas | Tyreek Hill | 174.08 |
8 | DeAndre Hopkins | Doug Baldwin | 173.84 |
9 | Demaryius Thomas | Allen Robinson | 173.81 |
10 | Doug Baldwin | Tyreek Hill | 173.62 |
11 | Brandin Cooks | Golden Tate | 172.37 |
12 | Demaryius Thomas | Michael Crabtree | 172.24 |
13 | DeAndre Hopkins | Michael Crabtree | 172.13 |
14 | Brandin Cooks | Tyreek Hill | 172.06 |
15 | DeAndre Hopkins | Allen Robinson | 171.96 |
16 | Demaryius Thomas | Alshon Jeffery | 171.67 |
17 | Doug Baldwin | Alshon Jeffery | 171.25 |
18 | Doug Baldwin | Allen Robinson | 171 |
19 | Brandin Cooks | Kelvin Benjamin | 170.95 |
20 | Brandin Cooks | Emmanuel Sanders | 170.9 |
21 | DeAndre Hopkins | Alshon Jeffery | 170.68 |
22 | Brandin Cooks | Allen Robinson | 170.68 |
23 | Brandin Cooks | Michael Crabtree | 170.6 |
24 | Brandin Cooks | Brandon Marshall | 169.39 |
25 | Demaryius Thomas | Jarvis Landry | 169.16 |
26 | Doug Baldwin | Michael Crabtree | 169.09 |
27 | Demaryius Thomas | Golden Tate | 169.06 |
28 | Brandin Cooks | Jarvis Landry | 169 |
29 | Demaryius Thomas | Martavis Bryant | 168.96 |
30 | Brandin Cooks | Davante Adams | 168.92 |
31 | Demaryius Thomas | DeVante Parker | 168.81 |
32 | Brandin Cooks | Larry Fitzgerald | 168.68 |
33 | Demaryius Thomas | Larry Fitzgerald | 168.58 |
34 | Brandin Cooks | DeSean Jackson | 168.22 |
35 | Demaryius Thomas | Davante Adams | 168.14 |
36 | Brandin Cooks | DeVante Parker | 168.12 |
37 | Demaryius Thomas | Keenan Allen | 168.03 |
38 | Demaryius Thomas | Kelvin Benjamin | 167.99 |
39 | Demaryius Thomas | Stefon Diggs | 167.7 |
40 | Tyreek Hill | Allen Robinson | 167.49 |
41 | Demaryius Thomas | DeSean Jackson | 167.48 |
42 | Demaryius Thomas | Sammy Watkins | 167.47 |
43 | Brandin Cooks | Terrelle Pryor | 167.44 |
44 | Allen Robinson | Michael Crabtree | 167.39 |
45 | Demaryius Thomas | Tyrell Williams | 167.37 |
46 | Demaryius Thomas | Brandon Marshall | 166.83 |
47 | DeAndre Hopkins | Terrelle Pryor | 166.79 |
48 | DeAndre Hopkins | Sammy Watkins | 166.65 |
49 | DeAndre Hopkins | Davante Adams | 166.54 |
50 | Doug Baldwin | Stefon Diggs | 166.42 |
51 | Doug Baldwin | Keenan Allen | 166.13 |
52 | DeAndre Hopkins | Stefon Diggs | 166.07 |
53 | DeAndre Hopkins | Larry Fitzgerald | 165.92 |
54 | Brandin Cooks | Sammy Watkins | 165.87 |
55 | Doug Baldwin | Golden Tate | 165.87 |
56 | Doug Baldwin | Martavis Bryant | 165.84 |
57 | Brandin Cooks | Alshon Jeffery | 165.68 |
58 | Tyreek Hill | Golden Tate | 165.62 |
59 | Doug Baldwin | Jarvis Landry | 165.56 |
60 | Alshon Jeffery | Allen Robinson | 165.4 |
61 | DeAndre Hopkins | Kelvin Benjamin | 165.3 |
62 | DeAndre Hopkins | Jarvis Landry | 165.27 |
63 | Doug Baldwin | Larry Fitzgerald | 165.22 |
64 | Tyreek Hill | Martavis Bryant | 165.15 |
65 | DeAndre Hopkins | Brandon Marshall | 165.07 |
66 | DeAndre Hopkins | DeVante Parker | 164.96 |
67 | DeAndre Hopkins | Keenan Allen | 164.96 |
68 | Doug Baldwin | Tyrell Williams | 164.96 |
69 | Doug Baldwin | Terrelle Pryor | 164.82 |
70 | DeAndre Hopkins | Emmanuel Sanders | 164.64 |
71 | Doug Baldwin | DeVante Parker | 164.61 |
72 | Doug Baldwin | Emmanuel Sanders | 164.39 |
73 | Doug Baldwin | Sammy Watkins | 164.37 |
74 | DeAndre Hopkins | DeSean Jackson | 164.16 |
75 | DeAndre Hopkins | Tyrell Williams | 164.16 |
76 | DeAndre Hopkins | Martavis Bryant | 164.07 |
77 | Doug Baldwin | Kelvin Benjamin | 164 |
78 | Doug Baldwin | DeSean Jackson | 163.92 |
79 | Doug Baldwin | Davante Adams | 163.66 |
80 | Tyreek Hill | Jarvis Landry | 163.55 |
81 | Tyreek Hill | Kelvin Benjamin | 163.47 |
82 | Tyreek Hill | Emmanuel Sanders | 163.35 |
83 | Tyreek Hill | Keenan Allen | 163.21 |
84 | Allen Robinson | Golden Tate | 162.49 |
85 | Tyreek Hill | Tyrell Williams | 162.36 |
86 | Tyreek Hill | DeVante Parker | 162.28 |
87 | Allen Robinson | Emmanuel Sanders | 162.2 |
88 | Allen Robinson | Kelvin Benjamin | 161.62 |
89 | Tyreek Hill | DeSean Jackson | 161.06 |
90 | Allen Robinson | Jarvis Landry | 161.04 |
91 | Allen Robinson | Martavis Bryant | 160.96 |
92 | Tyreek Hill | Davante Adams | 160.74 |
93 | Brandin Cooks | Keenan Allen | 160.71 |
94 | Tyreek Hill | Stefon Diggs | 160.62 |
95 | Brandin Cooks | Martavis Bryant | 160.47 |
96 | Doug Baldwin | Brandon Marshall | 160.42 |
97 | Demaryius Thomas | Terrelle Pryor | 160.19 |
98 | Brandin Cooks | Tyrell Williams | 160.16 |
99 | Allen Robinson | Terrelle Pryor | 160.12 |
100 | Alshon Jeffery | Golden Tate | 160.09 |
101 | Tyreek Hill | Larry Fitzgerald | 159.9 |
102 | Demaryius Thomas | Emmanuel Sanders | 159.79 |
103 | Demaryius Thomas | n/a | 159.79 |
Table 2: Wide Receiver Committee Pairs
Okay, that is a really big table, but I wanted to be thorough. As you can see, we have some very good pairs to select from for an elite WRBC. So digging in, there are 102 pairs ot Table 2 to consider, so there are a number of options. Rather than looking at the frequency of appearances, let's just jump right into the comparison to the original table for our Top 12+ wide receivers from the original article:
ADP | WR Rank | Player | Team | FPs |
1 | 1 | Antonio Brown | PIT | 205.12 |
2 | 2 | Odell Beckham Jr | NYG | 197.71 |
3 | 3 | Julio Jones | ATL | 190.24 |
4 | 4 | Mike Evans | TB | 187.15 |
5 | 6 | A.J. Green | CIN | 175.52 |
6 | 5 | Jordy Nelson | GB | 182.35 |
7 | 8 | Michael Thomas | NO | 168.64 |
8 | 7 | T.Y. Hilton | IND | 172.16 |
9 | 10 | Dez Bryant | DAL | 161.44 |
10 | 9 | Amari Cooper | OAK | 163.47 |
11 | 15 | DeAndre Hopkins | HOU | 150.03 |
12 | 13 | Doug Baldwin | SEA | 153.39 |
13 | 12 | Brandin Cooks | NE | 154.88 |
14 | 14 | Demaryius Thomas | DEN | 151.15 |
15 | 17 | Alshon Jeffery | PHI | 144.62 |
Table 3: Projected Fantasy Points for Elite Wide Receivers
PUTTING IT ALL TOGETHER
Based on Tables 2 and 3, we see that some combinations of wide receivers can afford elite production at a reduced price. Taking two wide receivers in the WR15-24 range with the right combined schedule gives 175+ fantasy points, which is equivalent to Michael Thomas (WR7 or WR8) along with seven points for a bye week filler. Not all of the pairings may fall into place in each draft, but having a chart like Table 2 can give you a leg up on the competition.
The committee approach is not a perfect one, but having this knowledge prior to your fantasy draft can prove to be invaluable if you decide to adopt this approach. If all the players on your starter list are gone, goiong with a committee can save your team and help you deal with the loss of bigger names. The method is also a big help in "Best Ball" leagues, where lineup decisions are not necessary every week. That's exactly where a committee can do the best, as either player can count for you each week.
Questions, suggestions and comments are always welcome to pasquino@footballguys.com.