Using SOS - Three-man Quarterback By Committees
Posted 8/8 by Clayton Gray, Exclusive to Footballguys.com
While we'd all love to be able to trot out a stud quarterback every week, that's often not feasible. If you don't want to spend a high pick on a quarterback (or if you mistakenly miss out on them), you'll likely turn to a quarterback by committee (QBBC). This article will focus on finding a three-player combo for your committee.
First off, we'll eliminate all of the QBs with an average draft position (ADP) in the first ten rounds. If we're going to go for a three-man committee, there is no point in wasting a high pick on a QB. That means, these players are not going to be in our player pool.
| Stud Quarterback |
ADP
|
| Tom Brady |
6
|
| Peyton Manning |
12
|
| Tony Romo |
18
|
| Drew Brees |
27
|
| Carson Palmer |
36
|
| Ben Roethlisberger |
44
|
| Derek Anderson |
52
|
| Matt Hasselbeck |
61
|
| Donovan McNabb |
63
|
| Jay Cutler |
76
|
| Marc Bulger |
80
|
| Eli Manning |
81
|
| David Garrard |
90
|
| Brett Favre |
96
|
| Jake Delhomme |
98
|
| Philip Rivers |
99
|
| Matt Schaub (Rosenfels) |
107
|
| Aaron Rodgers (Brohm) |
109
|
| Vince Young |
116
|
Now, let's identify the committee-worthy QBs. We'll exclude the QBs from Atlanta, Chicago, Kansas City, Baltimore, and Miami. In these cases, a starter hasn't been named nor is the eventual starter someone we want to rely upon as a vital part of our QBBC. That leaves us with the following QBs:
| Quarterback (and backup) |
ADP
|
| Jon Kitna |
125
|
| Jason Campbell |
133
|
| Matt Leinart (Warner) |
137
|
| Jeff Garcia |
158
|
| JaMarcus Russell |
172
|
| Tarvaris Jackson |
176
|
| Trent Edwards |
184
|
| Alex Smith (Hill/O'Sullivan) |
190
|
Note that two of the QBs above have a backup listed. In these cases, the backup is either someone you'll need to draft (Warner) or in a training camp battle (Hill and O'Sullivan).
Finally, we'll use SOS to determine which trio forms the most desirable QBBC. Below you will see all 56 possible combos ranked by the expected fantasy points (FtsyPts). You will also see a column labeled "ADP". The three numbers there are the ADP for the three QBs in the combo. The trick is to find a high-scoring combo that will be a relative bargain. As an added bonus, we've included the expected FtsyPts for the QBs that were excluded as well. This will easily allow you to see how your combo will measure up with those lone signal-callers.
QBBCs Ranked By Projected Fantasy Points Per Game
|
Rk
|
Lone QB or QB Combo |
ADP
|
FtsyPts
|
|
Lone QB
|
Tom Brady |
6
|
405.5
|
|
Lone QB
|
Peyton Manning |
12
|
353.8
|
|
Lone QB
|
Drew Brees |
27
|
338.6
|
|
Lone QB
|
Tony Romo |
18
|
334.0
|
|
Lone QB
|
Donovan McNabb |
63
|
326.4
|
|
Lone QB
|
Ben Roethlisberger |
44
|
315.2
|
|
1
|
J.Campbell, Leinart/Warner, & J.Garcia |
133, 137, & 158
|
314.3
|
|
2
|
J.Campbell, Leinart/Warner, & 49ers QB |
133, 137, & 190
|
312.1
|
|
3
|
J.Campbell, Leinart/Warner, & T.Jackson |
133, 137, & 176
|
310.0
|
|
4
|
J.Campbell, Leinart/Warner, & T.Edwards |
133, 137, & 184
|
309.9
|
|
5
|
J.Kitna, J.Campbell, & Leinart/Warner |
125, 133, & 137
|
309.6
|
|
Lone QB
|
Carson Palmer |
36
|
309.4
|
|
6
|
J.Kitna, Leinart/Warner, & J.Garcia |
125, 137, & 158
|
308.8
|
|
7
|
J.Campbell, Leinart/Warner, & J.Russell |
133, 137, & 172
|
308.8
|
|
8
|
Leinart/Warner, J.Garcia, & 49ers QB |
137, 158, & 190
|
308.6
|
|
9
|
J.Kitna, Leinart/Warner, & 49ers QB |
125, 137, & 190
|
305.6
|
|
10
|
Leinart/Warner, J.Garcia, & T.Jackson |
137, 158, & 176
|
304.9
|
|
11
|
Leinart/Warner, J.Garcia, & T.Edwards |
137, 158, & 184
|
304.9
|
|
12
|
Leinart/Warner, J.Garcia, & J.Russell |
137, 158, & 172
|
304.5
|
|
Lone QB
|
Matt Hasselbeck |
61
|
304.4
|
|
Lone QB
|
Matt Schaub & Sage Rosenfels |
107
|
304.4
|
|
13
|
J.Campbell, J.Garcia, & 49ers QB |
133, 158, & 190
|
304.2
|
|
14
|
J.Kitna, J.Campbell, & J.Garcia |
125, 133, & 158
|
303.9
|
|
15
|
J.Kitna, Leinart/Warner, & T.Jackson |
125, 137, & 176
|
303.7
|
|
16
|
J.Kitna, Leinart/Warner, & T.Edwards |
125, 137, & 184
|
303.6
|
|
17
|
J.Campbell, J.Garcia, & T.Jackson |
133, 158, & 176
|
303.0
|
|
18
|
Leinart/Warner, T.Edwards, & 49ers QB |
137, 184, & 190
|
302.6
|
|
19
|
J.Kitna, Leinart/Warner, & J.Russell |
125, 137, & 172
|
302.5
|
|
20
|
Leinart/Warner, T.Jackson, & 49ers QB |
137, 176, & 190
|
302.4
|
|
21
|
Leinart/Warner, J.Russell, & 49ers QB |
137, 172, & 190
|
301.8
|
|
Lone QB
|
Derek Anderson |
52
|
300.1
|
|
Lone QB
|
Aaron Rodgers |
109
|
300.0
|
|
22
|
J.Campbell, J.Garcia, & T.Edwards |
133, 158, & 184
|
299.2
|
|
23
|
J.Kitna, J.Campbell, & 49ers QB |
125, 133, & 190
|
299.0
|
|
24
|
J.Campbell, T.Jackson, & 49ers QB |
133, 176, & 190
|
298.6
|
|
25
|
J.Kitna, J.Garcia, & 49ers QB |
125, 158, & 190
|
298.6
|
|
26
|
Leinart/Warner, T.Jackson, & T.Edwards |
137, 176, & 184
|
297.9
|
|
Lone QB
|
Marc Bulger |
80
|
297.6
|
|
27
|
J.Campbell, T.Edwards, & 49ers QB |
133, 184, & 190
|
297.4
|
|
28
|
J.Kitna, J.Garcia, & T.Jackson |
125, 158, & 176
|
297.0
|
|
29
|
Leinart/Warner, J.Russell, & T.Jackson |
137, 172, & 176
|
296.9
|
|
30
|
J.Campbell, J.Garcia, & J.Russell |
133, 158, & 172
|
296.8
|
|
31
|
J.Campbell, J.Russell, & 49ers QB |
133, 172, & 190
|
296.6
|
|
32
|
J.Kitna, J.Garcia, & T.Edwards |
125, 158, & 184
|
296.2
|
|
Lone QB
|
Vince Young |
116
|
296.0
|
|
33
|
J.Kitna, J.Garcia, & J.Russell |
125, 158, & 172
|
295.9
|
|
34
|
J.Kitna, J.Campbell, & T.Jackson |
125, 133, & 176
|
295.8
|
|
35
|
J.Kitna, J.Campbell, & T.Edwards |
125, 133, & 184
|
295.8
|
|
36
|
J.Garcia, T.Jackson, & 49ers QB |
158, 176, & 190
|
295.7
|
|
37
|
J.Campbell, T.Jackson, & T.Edwards |
133, 176, & 184
|
295.6
|
|
Lone QB
|
David Garrard |
90
|
294.9
|
|
38
|
J.Kitna, J.Campbell, & J.Russell |
125, 133, & 172
|
294.4
|
|
39
|
J.Campbell, J.Russell, & T.Jackson |
133, 172, & 176
|
293.4
|
|
40
|
Leinart/Warner, J.Russell, & T.Edwards |
137, 172, & 184
|
293.1
|
|
41
|
J.Garcia, T.Edwards, & 49ers QB |
158, 184, & 190
|
292.9
|
|
42
|
J.Garcia, J.Russell, & 49ers QB |
158, 172, & 190
|
292.5
|
|
43
|
J.Garcia, T.Jackson, & T.Edwards |
158, 176, & 184
|
288.9
|
|
44
|
J.Kitna, T.Jackson, & 49ers QB |
125, 176, & 190
|
288.8
|
|
45
|
J.Garcia, J.Russell, & T.Jackson |
158, 172, & 176
|
288.5
|
|
46
|
J.Kitna, T.Edwards, & 49ers QB |
125, 184, & 190
|
288.4
|
|
47
|
J.Campbell, J.Russell, & T.Edwards |
133, 172, & 184
|
288.2
|
|
48
|
J.Kitna, J.Russell, & 49ers QB |
125, 172, & 190
|
287.8
|
|
49
|
J.Kitna, T.Jackson, & T.Edwards |
125, 176, & 184
|
282.9
|
|
50
|
J.Kitna, J.Russell, & T.Jackson |
125, 172, & 176
|
282.1
|
|
51
|
J.Garcia, J.Russell, & T.Edwards |
158, 172, & 184
|
281.5
|
|
52
|
T.Jackson, T.Edwards, & 49ers QB |
176, 184, & 190
|
280.2
|
|
53
|
J.Russell, T.Jackson, & 49ers QB |
172, 176, & 190
|
279.0
|
|
54
|
J.Kitna, J.Russell, & T.Edwards |
125, 172, & 184
|
278.9
|
|
Lone QB
|
Brett Favre |
96
|
276.4
|
|
Lone QB
|
Jay Cutler |
76
|
273.7
|
|
55
|
J.Russell, T.Edwards, & 49ers QB |
172, 184, & 190
|
272.6
|
|
Lone QB
|
Philip Rivers |
99
|
270.1
|
|
Lone QB
|
Jake Delhomme |
98
|
266.1
|
|
56
|
J.Russell, T.Jackson, & T.Edwards |
172, 176, & 184
|
264.3
|
|
Lone QB
|
Eli Manning |
81
|
256.5
|
Note that the stud QBs' "FtsyPts" include the average points that a mediocre backup QB would score during their bye week.















